Computing editor Bryan Glick on the issues facing UK IT leaders and the latest in internet and business technology Computing editor Bryan Glick on the issues facing UK IT leaders and the latest in internet and business technology Computing editor Bryan Glick on the issues facing UK IT leaders and the latest in internet and business technology

« When you say nothing at all | Main | The centre of the world? »

Thursday, 30 August 2007

Why IT exams are a waste of time

Science exams are to be made easier to encourage more pupils to study, and so reverse the declining demand for the subject in schools. Well, they might as well do the same with computer studies and IT courses because they are clearly a waste of time.

What other conclusions can you draw from the continued fall in the number of technology GCSE and A-level exams being studied? Students are not interested in learning the subject. Universities do not bother to mandate computer A-levels as a pre-requisite for degrees in the subject. And according to the continuing letters from Computing readers, few employers are bothered about whether or not potential candidates have academic qualifications in IT at any level.

So are we on the verge of a time when IT employers will completely disregard the exam history of new entrants to the profession? Accountancy firms would never choose trainees without passing maths exams, no junior doctors would be allowed to avoid studying medicine, and no solicitor would make the grade without learning law. Personal attributes such as enthusiasm, aptitude and communication skills are vital criteria of course, but should IT as a recruiting profession be left to rely solely on these subjective judgements?

The sad fact is that IT employers are becoming increasingly divorced from the academic institutions that are meant to be preparing young people for a career in IT.

When A-level results were published earlier this month, the Department for Children, Schools and Families justified the drop in IT exams by telling Computing that ‘many young people interested in IT are taking alternative vocational routes rather than A-level.’ That just about says it all really – even the government aren’t bothered and expect pupils to find another way into IT rather than through A-levels, which one can only assume it tacitly acknowledges are not worth the screen they are printed from.

There will of course be exceptions – the technically-focused nature of many degree courses no doubt prepare interested graduates for careers in research or software programming. Just don’t mention that more and more firms outsource programming to India or elsewhere.

The most worrying aspect of this trend is that IT employers no longer seem to care about the inability of academia to prepare young people for a career in the profession. It is just accepted as a fact. Will the new IT Diploma make a difference? Let us hope so – but if the basic exam qualifications that every child goes through are so irrelevant to our industry, there is a more fundamental problem that surely has to be addressed.

What do you think?

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/1105496/21203601

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Why IT exams are a waste of time:

Comments

Blame the schools....at 14 my son sat the IT Olympiad exams and finished in the top 10% at Under 19 standard. His school (a Technical Grammar) refused to let him sit an O level, describing it as a subject with no value for his future. Instead he had the pleaseure of doing Latin and designing a clay shoe for Graphics..both of which will really benefit him later.

I home educate my children and have encountered several home educating parents say that qualifications mean nothing to employers and aren't even worth the paper they are printed on. The majority of home educated children do not sit any GCSEs or gain any qualifications at all. Instead, they learn life skills and how to succeed as an adult. Despite the howls of anguish from those who believe in the state school system and the importance of GCSEs, most home educated children succeed in the job market and few end up unemployed.

The state education system teaches a load of theoretical rubbish that is of no use as an adult. University is just a con trick for the naive of society unless you are studying medicine or law.

Home education and self education are the way forwards. Institutionalised education and exams are relics of the 20th century.

Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In


Contacts

Powered by TypePad
© 1995-2006 All rights reserved